The ideal goal of treatment for a heel bone fracture is to restore the dimensions of the heel as accurately as possible. This is always difficult because of the multiple fragments of bone that are commonly present. For the majority of patients, surgery is the best treatment option. The goal of surgery is to restore the correct size and structure of the heel. This is done by performing an open reduction and internal fixation of the fracture.
The open reduction and internal fixation procedure is performed through an incision on the outside of the heel. The bone is put together and held in place with multiple screws. This procedure decreases the likelihood of arthritis developing and maximizes the potential for inward and outward movement of the foot.
There are times, however, when the bone is so severely smashed and fractured that, in addition to the open reduction and internal fixation, the heel joint (the subtalar joint) needs to be fused. This is done to decrease the chances of developing painful arthritis. Although the inversion and eversion movement of the foot is lost after a subtalar fusion, there is a more rapid return to activities and functions after this type of surgery.
Following a fracture of the calcaneus, there are many potential problems which can occur. To some extent, this depends on the type of treatment provided. The problems which occur commonly are as follows:
- Pain in the back of the heel on the outside of the ankle. This is present in the heel joint (the subtalar joint), and is usually because of arthritis in this joint.
- Stiffness in the subtalar joint. Regardless of the type of treatment, there is always some limitation of the in and out movement of the foot. This is called inversion and eversion. The problem occurs because of damage to the cartilage surface of joint, which is often associated with arthritis.
- Widening of the back of the heel and difficulty with wearing shoes. This problem occurs predominantly when surgery is not performed initially and the heel remains wide and deformed.
- Pain on the outside of the heel and the outside of the ankle occurs due to injury to the tendons (the peroneal tendons). This is a more common problem when surgery is not performed initially and is because of widening of the heel bone. The peroneal tendons can be torn in the process.
- Pain under the pad of the heel. This is unfortunately a permanent problem, since the specialized fatty cushion under the heel can be permanently damaged with injury. This can only be treated with correct cushioning and padding of the heel.
- Burning pain on the inside of the ankle. This can occur as a result of widening of the inside of the heel on the inside of the ankle, which causes irritation of the tibial nerve (called a tarsal tunnel syndrome).
- Pain in the ankle, which occurs in severe forms of fracture which are not treated with surgery. The heel bone is severely crushed, which leads to jamming of the front of the ankle.
Arthritis of the heel joint will lead to pain in the outside of the ankle and stiffness of the back of the foot. Walking on uneven ground surfaces is difficult since the inversion and eversion movement of the subtalar joint is missing. The treatments can consist of anti-inflammatory medication, injection of the subtalar joint with cortisone, special arch supports and heel cushions, and surgery.
When surgery is necessary to correct the problem, the longer it takes to perform this surgery after a fracture of the calcaneus, the longer it will take to return the individual back to a more normal lifestyle, in particular heavy work.
There are many different types of surgery that can be performed and this is determined by the severity of the deformity, the presence of arthritis and other problems such as tearing of tendons, pain in the ankle and widening of the heel.
When the deformity of the heel is not severe and there is minor arthritis, then all that may need to be done is to remove the excess bone under the outside of the ankle. The problem is called impingement where bone from the broken calcaneus rubs on the under side of the ankle causing pain.
When the arthritis in the subtalar joint following a calcaneus fracture is more significant, a fusion of the joint is necessary. A fusion is where the surgeon removes the remaining cartilage from both sides of the arthritic joint and roughens up the underlying bone to make it bleed. The two sides of the joint are then compressed together with screws to make the two bones heal together into one single bone. This eliminates the pain from the arthritic joint surfaces rubbing together.
When the deformity of the heel is more severe, a fusion of the subtalar joint is not sufficient and a piece of bone (called a bone graft) is placed into the joint to restore the more normal dimension of the heel.